We’ve been using GoCardless over at Childcare.co.uk for quite some time, the service is fine but I personally think it’s too slow for small sums. It can be pretty bad depending on how the weekend falls in the cycle as well. Here’s the estimated schedule for a subscription that was taken up today:
Payment created - 24 Nov 2014
Payment submitted to Bacs - 27 Nov 2014
Payment scheduled to leave customer’s account - 1 Dec 2014
Payment confirmed and received by GoCardless - 2 Dec 2014
Paid out to merchant - 4 Dec 2014
Here’s the schedule for an upgrade that failed:
Payment created - 1 Nov 2014
Payment submitted to Bacs - 5 Nov 2014
Payment failed - instruction cancelled by payer or the payer’s bank - 10 Nov 2014
We give them the benefit of the doubt when signing up as we want a decent experience, so that user enjoyed our service free of charge for 9 days.